Vouchers
are back in Bush's speech
From the USA Today, July 2, 2002
By Laurence McQuillanCLEVELAND - President Bush said
Monday that he will encourage every state to develop tuition voucher programs to help poor
children escape failing public schools.
On a trip to Cleveland, whose 6-year-old voucher program
was upheld by the Supreme Court on Thursday, Bush said the court "gave a great
victory to parents and students throughout the nation." He drew thunderous applause
at the historic State Theatre from 3,000 people, many of whom are from the inner-city
communities where vouchers are popular.
The court's 5-4 ruling validated a Cleveland program that
gives as much as $2,250 a year to parents to help them pay tuition and other costs at
private schools, including schools with religious affiliation. The court said the funds do
not violate a constitutional ban on promoting religion.
The president compared the ruling to the historic Brown vs.
Board of Education decision in 1954 outlawing "separate but equal" schools that
segregated white and black students.
Bush has long supported the idea of vouchers, although he
had dropped the words from his speech vocabulary because it set off arguments. He dropped
the voucher part of his education bill in order to get it passed.
Opponents say voucher programs threaten public schools
because they siphon off taxpayers' money.
"It is a constructive approach to improving public
education," Bush said. "We're interested in aiming toward excellence for every
child, and the voucher system is a part of the strategy."
He called on Congress to pass a $2,500-per-child education
tax credit for families whose children leave failing public schools for private schools.
The five-year, $3.5 billion proposal would cover tuition, books, computers, other supplies
and transportation. That proposal, a top goal of conservatives, has little chance of being
enacted in an election year because of strong opposition by teachers' unions and civil
liberties groups.
The Rev. Barry Lynn, executive director of Americans United
for Separation of Church and State, criticized Bush's proposal.
"There's nothing compassionate about forcing Americans
to support religion," he said. "There's nothing conservative about requiring
people to pay for religious indoctrination."
Today Bush visits Milwaukee, which has the nation's largest
school voucher program. This year, more than 10,000 children from poor families attend
private schools using vouchers.
Florida has the only other voucher program, started in 1999
by Gov. Jeb Bush, the president's brother. Eight thousand children participate in 10
public school districts around the state.
In Washington, the Education Department released estimates
that there are 3.5 million students nationwide - nearly 7% of public school enrollment -
attending about 8,600 failing public schools.
The president's trip Monday, his seventh to Ohio, opened a
week of travel to important political states. He lost narrowly to Al Gore in 2000 in
Wisconsin. The Fourth of July trip to West Virginia will be Bush's fourth to the
traditionally Democratic state, which Bush won. |