Vouchers
Still Face Long Road
Thursday, June 27, 2002
By GREG TOPPO AP Education Writer WASHINGTON (AP) -
Lawmakers in eight states are poised to push school voucher legislation, now that the
Supreme Court has ruled that these programs do not violate the Constitution's requirement
of separation of church and state.
But parents should not expect their local parochial school
to begin offering taxpayer-subsidized slots in the first grade this fall. States first
would have to devise such programs and the political process to put them in place
inevitably will be slow.
California, Texas, Colorado, Minnesota, Arizona, Indiana,
Virginia and Utah are ready to move. And on Capitol Hill, House Majority Leader Dick
Armey, R-Texas, plans to introduce a voucher program for students in the District of
Columbia.
Even supporters of vouchers - or school-choice programs, as
they call them - say it could take months or even a year or two for state legislatures to
develop similar programs.
Further complicating matters is the question of whether
religious and private schools that take government money must comply with laws on
disability and civil rights.
"The real debate now rests with the American people,
state by state," said Wendy Puriefoy, president of the Public Education Network, an
association of community-based education organizations.
In the 1999-2000 school year, there were 46.9 million
public school students; approximately 5 million students were in private school, according
to Education Department figures.
Last year, 50 new Catholic schools opened, but 90 older
ones - mainly in urban areas of the Northeast - closed.
"The number of schools that we lose each year is
likely to diminish, but none of that will happen quickly," said Michael J. Guerra,
president of the National Catholic Educational Association.
Thursday's decision, he said, could help inner-city
Catholic schools, many of which face declining enrollment.
Robert A. Destro, co-director of the Law and Religion
program at Catholic University, said restrictive laws in many states on church-state
separation could be "problematic."
Attorney David Brennan, who helped design the Cleveland
program, said the ruling "will remove a tremendous chilling effect" on
legislators who worried that their voucher proposals would be challenged in court.
"The dialogue will now change," he said.
"You'll have bills introduced, you'll have hearings, you'll have all sorts of
legislative activity all around the country, now that this issue has been settled."
In Ohio, Destro and Brennan, said the most likely
short-term effect is that the Legislature will move to increase the amount that students
receive, which would make it more attractive to private schools.
"Now that the constitutional cork is off the bottle,
they can actually put some money behind it and give these inner-city kids some real
choices," Destro said.
The maximum is now $2,250, but most students receive only
$1,600 - far below what most private schools and even most parochial schools charge for
tuition.
President Bush has championed vouchers, but Congress last
year shelved his effort to give students up to $1,500 in federal funds for private-school
tuition. The president resurrected the idea in his 2003 budget, proposing to give families
up to $2,500 per child in tax credits if they choose a private school rather than a
failing neighborhood public school.
Sen. Edward Kennedy, D-Mass., said any voucher proposals
probably would fail in the Senate.
Copyright 2002
The Associated Press All Rights Reserved |