Bush
Calls Ruling About Vouchers a 'Historic' Move
From the New York Times, July 2, 2002
By ELISABETH BUMILLERCLEVELAND, July 1 - President
Bush today hailed last week's Supreme Court decision upholding the use of public money for
religious school tuition as "just as historic" as the landmark 1954 ruling that
school segregation was unconstitutional, and he declared that the United States could not
have separate education systems for the rich and the poor.
In his first public comments on the ruling, Mr. Bush
plunged into the politically explosive issue of school vouchers that he had so far avoided
as president.
Although Mr. Bush had tried to include vouchers in a major
education bill he signed early this year, he quickly gave up when he saw that there was
not enough support from Congressional leaders for the program.
The president's speech today, in the city that established
the voucher program upheld by the Supreme Court on Thursday, signaled that he now felt he
had the opening to push aggressively on the issue.
In the 2000 presidential campaign, Mr. Bush supported
voucher programs but rarely if ever used the word, a reflection of how divided American
voters were on the issue.
"The Supreme Court of the United States gave a great
victory to parents and students throughout the nation by upholding the decisions made by
local folks here in the city of Cleveland, Ohio," Mr. Bush said to loud applause at
the Playhouse Square Center on the eastern edge of downtown.
Advocates of vouchers have praised the 5-to-4 ruling as the
most important Supreme Court decision on education since the segregation ruling, Brown v.
Board of Education.
Today was the first time, however, that the president said
he agreed with them.
"The Supreme Court in 1954 declared that our nation
cannot have two education systems," Mr. Bush said. "And that was the right
decision. Can't have two systems, one for African-Americans and one for whites.
"Last week, what's notable and important is that the
court declared that our nation will not accept one education system for those who can
afford to send their children to a school of their choice and for those who can't. And
that's just as historic."
Vouchers, Mr. Bush said, are "a constructive approach
to improving public education."
"We're interested in aiming toward excellence for
every child," he continued. "And the voucher system is a part of the strategy to
achieve that here in Cleveland."
Although vouchers are not popular with all Republicans,
particularly those who moved to the suburbs for better schools, they are strongly
supported by low-income African-Americans whose children attend poor-quality city schools.
Mr. Bush received little support in the last presidential election from black voters and
his political advisers are eager to increase his support among African-Americans in any
way they can.
Today before an audience of nearly 3,000 people, Mr. Bush
singled out a black Cleveland resident who is an advocate for vouchers, Roberta Kitchen.
"Where's Roberta?" Mr. Bush asked from the stage,
then found her and waved.
"Hi, Roberta," he said. "Roberta is a mom of
five children, and her passion is a passion which is shared by moms all across America.
Her passion is pretty simple: I want my children to go to a safe school where he or she
can realize their full potential."
Conservatives predicted after the Supreme Court decision
last week that Mr. Bush would be forced to embrace vouchers more publicly. Democrats not
unhappily agreed, and asserted that Mr. Bush would become more identified with the right -
notwithstanding vouchers' appeal to urban blacks - and less of the centrist leader he has
tried to become in education.
Mr. Bush's embrace of vouchers today was quickly criticized
by Senator Edward M. Kennedy, Democrat of Massachusetts, a leading sponsor of the
education bill. The senator allied himself with Mr. Bush for the passage of the bill, but
rebuffed him in his efforts to add vouchers. Mr. Kennedy has also been increasingly at
odds with the president over what he considers the administration's failure to provide
enough money to finance the bill's goals.
"Private school vouchers may pass constitutional
muster, but they fail the test when it comes to improving our nation's public
schools," Mr. Kennedy said in a statement. "It's flat wrong to take scarce
taxpayer dollars away from public schools and divert them to private schools."
Under Cleveland's six-year-old program, about 3,700 of the
district's 75,000 children use vouchers worth up to $2,250 to help pay for private school
tuition. Nearly all of these students attend religious schools. Today, Education Secretary
Rod Paige called the city "ground zero for freedom of choice in public schools"
as he introduced Mr. Bush.
The president, in an unusually long 38-minute address to
people from school choice organizations and charities, spent much of his time promoting
his education legislation, the No Child Left Behind law, which mandates annual testing of
children in Grades 3 to 8 and offers tutoring for students in failing schools.
"It's easy to walk into a classroom full of inner-city
African-Americans, for example, and say, `You can't learn, we'll move you through,' "
Mr. Bush said. "Or how about classrooms full of children whose parents don't speak
English as a first language - it's easy to quit on those kids. Heck, it's hard to educate
a child whose parents don't speak English; why don't we just shuffle them through the
system?
"That means you have low hopes, low standards, low
expectations. We start with a different premise: every child can learn, regardless of
their circumstances."
Mr. Bush also used his two hours and 45 minutes in a
politically crucial state that he won comfortably in 2000 to remind voters of his
"compassionate conservative" agenda. Today he promoted his changes to the
welfare laws, his plan to give federal money to religious charities and his program to
increase home ownership among minorities.
He also, as he almost does, spoke of the campaign against
terrorism, but he said that he was not only interested in war.
"Oh, I know that in the midst of this war there is a
lot of warlike talk, and I'm as guilty as - I'm guilty," Mr. Bush said, to laughter.
"I talk that way. But I want you to know, I love peace." |