Lines drawn on cloning of embryos
From the Plain Dealer, Novemeber 27, 2001
Sabrina Eaton
Plain Dealer BureauWashington- A biotechnology
firm's announcement that it cloned a human embryo generated outrage yesterday, prompting
lawmakers to renew calls for an immediate ban on human cloning.
President Bush said the experiments, in which Massachusetts-based Advanced Cell Technology
inserted outside genetic material in human eggs and got them to divide into six-cell
embryos, were "morally wrong, in my opinion."
"We should not, as a society, grow life to destroy
it," said Bush, who has banned the use of federal funds for such research. "And
that's exactly what's taking place."
The company's CEO, Michael West, said he has no interest in
cloning human beings. West said he wants to use the technique so humans can create
replacement body parts compatible with their own genetic material.
Carl Feldbaum, president of the Biotechnology Industry
Organization trade group, added that the technology could lead to treatments and cures for
diseases including diabetes and Parkinson's disease.
"Reproductive cloning is untested, unsafe and morally
repugnant," Feldbaum said in a statement. "We understand that ACT intends to use
this technology solely for therapeutic purposes."
West insists that the cloned embryos are merely clumps of
cells. But critics of the technology, including religious and environmental groups, insist
that it upsets nature's careful balance and that the embryos are humans who should not be
used for spare parts.
The Catholic Church said in a statement released from the
Vatican: "Despite the declared humanistic' intentions by those who predict
sensational cures via this path . . . what is needed is a calm but firm judgment which
shows the moral gravity of this plan and which motivates an unequivocal
condemnation."
Sen. Sam Brownback, a Kansas Republican, accused the
researchers of "treating human embryos like cattle or frog eggs." He demanded
that the Senate immediately pass a human cloning ban that the House adopted in a 265-162
vote in July.
"Our government cannot sit idly by as mad scientists
redefine what it means to be human beings," added Rep. Chris Smith, New Jersey
Republican, who forecast establishment of human embryo farms to create "guinea
pigs" for experiments.
Senate Majority Leader Tom Daschle has promised that the
Senate will vote on cloning in February or March and doesn't plan to change that
timetable, said spokesman Jay Carson. The South Dakota Democrat has said he backs research
use of cloning, but opposes its use for human replication.
On Fox News Sunday, Daschle called news of the research
"disconcerting."
"I think it's going in the wrong direction,"
Daschle added.
Ohio Sens. Mike DeWine and George Voinovich, both
Republican, say they want the Senate to ban cloning swiftly.
"As science advances, the cloning of human embryos
remains morally wrong and Congress needs to act to make it illegal," DeWine said in a
statement.
Contact Sabrina Eaton at:
seaton@plaind.com, 216-999-4212 |