Lawmakers
Face Legal Battle Over Lottery Plan
by Tom Chansky
From the Ohio News Network, January
15, 2002 An Ohio political group has sued the state
over its latest attempt to raise money.
Tuesday, the Ohio Roundtable announced a lawsuit against
the state seeking to block Ohio from entering a multi-state lottery, such as Powerball or
the Big Game. The Roundtable and other anti-gambling groups say in 1988, the Ohio Attorney
General ruled that a lottery run with other states would be unconstitutional. Ohio
Roundtable President David Zanotti says the group will spend between $50,000 and $100,000
on radio and television advertisements.
The lawsuit says legislation authorizing the state to join
a lottery violates the Ohio Constitution, which prohibits the state from delegating
authority over a lottery to other states. The lawsuit seeks a temporary injunction
blocking Ohio from joining a multistate lottery.
In September, Governor Bob Taft announced the state was
facing a $1.5 billion budget deficit. State lawmakers passed a round of budget cuts and a
number of other measures to balance the budget. One of those measures planned for Ohio to
join a multi-state lottery. State estimates report Ohio could earn more than $41 million
per year with a multi-state lottery. Ohio lottery officials say they lose between $200
million and $300 million each year because Ohioans travel across the border to try to win
big jackpots like Powerball.
Governor Taft's office tells ONN the governor will ask Ohio
Attorney General Betty Montgomery to fight the lawsuit.
Over the past four years, as multi-state lotteries have
seen soaring popularity across the nation, the Ohio Lottery Commission has seen declining
revenues.
"The states around us do offer multi-jurisdictional
gaming that traditionally has larger jackpots than we have, so all of that leads to a
decline in sales for the Ohio Lottery," Mardele Cohen, Spokesperson for the Ohio
Lottery tells ONN.
However, anti-gambling groups don't buy the state's
argument. Reverend John Edgar, with the Anti-Lottery Commission, says it is horrible
public policy to "be selling a product that harms our citizens." Anti-gambling
groups say the incentive to win larger jackpots will lead the state to moral and legal
problems.
However, lawmakers say they realize the gravity of the
situation. Along with passing the multi-state lottery bill, lawmakers tacked on a
provision to create a gambling study to determine its effect on the state.
Last year, the University of Cincinnati's Ohio Poll found
53 percent of Ohioans supported the state joining a multi-state lottery. Out of all the
people who said they favor the proposal, the largest amount, 29 percent, said that they
favor joining a multi-state lottery because it would raise money for education. Of the 39
percent of people opposing the idea, 13 percent said that Ohio's current lottery is not
working or that the money does not go to the state's schools.
Ohioans twice voted against casinos statewide votes in 1990
and 1996.
© The Ohio News Network, 2002. All rights reserved. This
material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. AP contributed to
this report. |